The PB All-Star Teams

[Rockies GM (Dan)]

Thought it would be fun to put together All-Star teams for this league at a little past our halfway point and see what they look like. For the sake of simplicity, most of my decisions are based off the Fantrax player rating system.

NL All-Stars

Starting Lineup
C Russel Martin (Giants)
CI Josh Donaldson (Cardinals)
CI Anthony Rizzo (Cubs)
MI Jason Kipnis (Braves)
MI Dee Gordon (Giants)
OF Bryce Haper (Braves)
OF Mike Trout (Rockies)
OF Justin Upton (Diamondbacks)

Rotation and Main Relievers
SP Gerrit Cole (Rockies)
SP Chris Archer (Rockies)
SP Sonny Gray (Dodgers)
SP Felix Hernandez (Nationals)
SP Jacob DeGrom (Cubs)
RP Dellin Betances (Diamondbacks)
RP Wade Davis (Rockies)
RP Carson Smith (Rockies)

Bench & Bullpen
C Derek Norris (Braves)
CI Miguel Cabrera (Braves)
CI Joey Votto (Reds)
MI Kolten Wong (Padres)
MI Dustin Pedroia (Nationals)
OF George Springer (Phillies)
OF Lorenzo Cain (Nationals)
SP Dallas Keuchel (Reds)
SP Chris Sale (Dodgers)
SP Matt Harvey (Phillies)
RP Andrew Miller (Phillies)
RP Pat Neshek (Diamondbacks)

NL All-Rookie Team
A Note: These were based on a mix of performance this year with future projection
C JT Realmuto (Brewers) (I thought about putting another Brewer, Schwarber, here, but I don't expect the Cubs to keep him up long)
CI Kris Bryant (Giants)
CI Matt Duffy (Reds)
MI Carlos Correa (Rockies)
MI Devon Travis (Padres)
OF Billy Burns (Rockies)
OF Randal Grichuk (Reds)
OF Jorge Soler (Cubs)
SP Lance McCullers (Nationals)
SP Nathan Karns (Mets)
SP Aaron Sanchez (Rockies)
SP Trevor May (Padres)
SP Eduardo Rodriguez (Pirates)
RP Carson Smith (Rockies)
RP Roberto Osuna (Rockies)
RP Keone Kela (Cubs)

AL All-Stars

Starting Lineup
C Stephen Vogt (Angels)
CI Paul Goldschmidt (Indians)
CI Todd Frazier (White Sox)
MI Brian Dozier (Orioles)
MI Jhonny Peralta (Yankees)
OF Giancarlo Stanton (Astros)
OF Nelson Cruz (Tigers)
OF Starling Marte (Astros)

Rotation and Main Relievers
SP Max Scherzer (Indians
SP Zack Greinke (Orioles)
SP Michael Wacha (Yankees)
SP David Price (Rangers)
SP Madison Bumgarner (Yankees
RP Jeurys Familia (Rangers)
RP Trevor Rosenthal (Yankees)
RP David Robertson (Angels)

Bench & Bullpen
C Buster Posey (Yankees)
CI Manny Machado (Rangers)
CI Freddie Freeman (Red Sox)
MI Brandon Crawford (Astros)
MI Jose Altuve (Giants)
OF AJ Pollock (Twins)
OF Brett Gardner (Blue Jays)
SP Clayton Kershaw (Rays)
SP AJ Burnett (Pirates)
SP Michael Pineda (Yankees)
RP Drew Storen (Twins)
RP Tony Watson (Angels)

AL All-Rookie Team
A Note: These were based on a mix of performance this year with future projection
C Blake Swihart (Yankees)
CI Joey Gallo (Royals)
CI Maikel Franco (Royals)
MI Eddie Rosario (Blue Jays)
MI Addison Russell (Brewers)
OF Joc Pederson (Yankees)
OF Steven Souza, Jr (Orioles)
OF Yasmany Tomas (Mariners)
SP Chris Heston (Angels)
SP Chi Chi Gonzalez (Rangers)
SP Anthony DeSclafani (Astros)
SP Carlos Rodon (Yankees)
SP Noah Syndergaard (Yankees)
SP Michael Lorenzen (Reds)
RP Yimi Garcia (Rays)
RP Andrew Chafin (Yankees)


SO...who got snubbed?

[Former Angels GM (Mike C.)]

all the Royals players....

[Cubs GM (Beau)]

From the beginning, I have assumed all the Royals going to the All-Star game was the result of Mike tirelessly creating thousands of fake email addresses and voting the maximum amount of times each...